| 2021 | Lauren Southworth |
| 2018 | Taylor Mulder |
| 2012 | Hannah Ulrich |
| 2010 | Haley Mancini |
| 2009 | Allison Septer |
| 2008 | Amanda Marinello |
| 2006 | Christine Coleman |
| 2005 | Carey Canty |
| 2004 | Kara McKeon |
| 2001 | Lacey Wilmot |
| 2000 | Nicole Tobin |
| 1997 | Amy Gillin |
| 1994 | Amy Daniel |
| 1991 | Debra Baierl |
| 1990 | Shelly Vanderveen |
| 1989 | Abby English |
(Updated 6/16/2022)
