| 2023 |
Sarah Ammon |
| 2022 |
Sarah Ammon Julia Anderson Katie Carver Gia Diaz Olivia Emert Alyssa Fischer Caitlyn Harwood Berenice Huette-Moncelet Kennedy Hyde Christina Ibanez-Merino Kaitlyn Jacobs Laura Kaceli Ashley Kraiza Morgan Llewellyn Rachel Lynch Evelyn Marx Hannah Moening Ashton Parker Mackenzie Pettey Danielle Powell Isabel Remar Kayla Rivers Lily Tiplady Erin Tyson Kendall Wise Marissa Young Sophie Zelek |
| 2021 |
Julia Anderson Kara Bishop Katie Carver Olivia Emert Caitlyn Harwood Isabel Herden Berenice Huette-Moncelet Kiley Kaczmarek Ashley Kraiza Kaleigh Mahaz Danielle Powell Isabel Remar Lauren Southworth Erin Tyson Marissa Young |
| 2020 | Kara Bishop Haylie Curtiss Mia Dronchi Isabel Herden Kiley Kaczmarek Macy Llewellyn Kaleigh Mahaz Jennifer Richmond Alexa Scroggie Lauren Southworth Ashley Strong |
| 2019 | Kara Bishop Haylie Curtiss Mia Dronchi Kathryn Gordon Isabel Herden Kiley Kaczmarek Macy Llewellyn Kaleigh Mahaz Madeline Reau Jennifer Richmond Magali Romero Alexa Scroggie Lauren Southworth Julia Stancato Ashley Strong (NAIA Team Award) |
| 2018 | Kelsey Cheaney Kathryn Gordon Taylor Mulder Madeline Reau (NAIA Team Award) |
| 2017 | Taylor Hill Erin Scheidel Rachel Sherman Taylor Mulder Madison Tedora |
| 2016 |
Morgan Behn |
| 2015 | Morgan Behn Gabi Corbin Emily Loar Brittany Trout Madison Phillips |
| 2014 | Jori Bitter Elizabeth Davis Meg Dubois Mikayla Ferer Abbey Marlette Megan Michels Carlee Pallett Madison Phillips (NAIA Team Award) |
| 2013 | Jori Bitter Elizabeth Davis Meg Dubois Lynn Hendricks Abbey Marlette Megan Michels Meagan Mousty (NAIA Team Award) |
| 2012 | Lynn Hendricks Mackenzy Hickner Alyssa Hoff Hannah Ulrich Alessia Vagnini |
| 2011 | Alyssa Hoff Hannah Ulrich Alessia Vagnini (NAIA Team Award) |
| 2010 | (NAIA Team Award) |
| 2009 | Stephanie Hayden |
| 2008 | Stephanie Hayden Amanda Marinello Kati Saul Kim Stoutenburg Ashley Wilmot (NAIA Team Award) |
| 2007 | Allison Davis Paula Sanematsu Kati Saul Kim Stoutenburg Maggie Vaillancourt (NAIA Team Award) |
| 2006 |
Christine Coleman |
| 2005 | Carey Canty Christine Coleman |
| 2004 | Carey Canty Allison Steudle |
| 2002 | Amy Debner Kristen Wickenheiser |
| 2001 | Amy Debner Kristen Wickenheiser Lacey Wilmot |
| 2000 | Lacey Wilmot |
| 1997 | Amy Gillin |
| 1996 | Amy Gillin |
| 1995 | Amy Daniel |
| 1994 | Deanna Kaprelian |
| 1993 | Amy Daniel |
| 1992 | Debra Baierl |
| 1989 | Shelly Vanderveen Audra Wheeler |
(Updated 12/04/23)
