| 2017 |
Emily Burkman |
| 2016 |
Samantha Bartelotti |
| 2015 | Samantha Bartelotti Emily Burkman Taylor Mulder |
| 2014 | Alexis Donnelly Kelsey Young |
| 2011 | Hannah Ulrich |
| 2010 | Katelyn Hawarny Lindsey Mancini |
| 2009 | Gemma Cowperthwaite Haley Mancini |
| 2008 | Haley Mancini Allison Septer |
| 2006 | Carol Roman Nikki Romano |
| 2004 | Kelly Tubbs |
| 2003 | Kara McKeon Rebecca Meier |
| 2002 | Stephanie Schaffron Stacey Koehler-Jacobs Kara McKeon |
| 2001 | Dawn O'Neil Lacey Wilmot |
| 2000 | Nicole Tobin |
| 1999 | Nicole Tobin Lacey Wilmot |
| 1998 | Nicole Tobin |
| 1995 | Natalia Hernandez Ayana Nash |
| 1993 |
Colleen Baierl |
| 1992 | Debra Baierl Ayana Nash |
| 1990 | Tami Simon Shelly Vanderveen |
| 1989 | Lisa Broccardo |
| 1986 | Abby English |
(Updated 6/16/2022)
