All-WHAC
| Year | Name | Team |
| 2023 | Marc Arsenault Zak Tucker |
Second Team Second Team |
| 2022 | Ramon Matos Joudiel Poveymirow Zak Tucker |
Second Team Second Team Second Team |
| 2021 | Shevin Blades Keegan Crawford Joudiel Poveymirow |
First Team First Team First Team |
| 2020 | Emilier DeJesus | First Team |
| 2019 | Alex Garavalia Keegan Crawford Emilier DeJesus |
Second Team |
All-Independent
| Year | Name | Team |
| 2018 | Kyle Browne Tyler Hubbard-Neil |
Second Team Second Team |
| 2017 | Matthew Dugan | First Team |
All-MEC
| Year | Name | Team |
| 2016 | Matthew Dugan Tyler Hubbard-Neil John Kalugar Jeff Hardman |
First Team First Team First Team Second Team |
All-MAMVIC Great Lakes
| Year | Name | Team |
| 2014 | Gilius Blinstrubas | First Team |
| 2012 | Juan Sierra Brandon Bowers |
First Team Honorable Mention |
| 2011 | Juan Sierra Adrian Rutt |
First Team Second Team |
| 2010 | Matt Mitterholzer Juan Sierra Adrian Rutt |
First Team First Team Honorable Mention |
Updated: 12/21/23
