| 2018 | Justin Gray | D | Second Team |
| 2017 | Rahbar Khan | M | Second Team |
| 2013 | Matthew Robinet | D | Honorable Mention |
| 2012 | Shane Patterson | M | First Team |
| 2011 | Doug Dawson Joe Deneweth |
D F |
Second Team Honorable Mention |
| 2010 | Doug Dawson Joe Deneweth Lindon Ivezic |
D/M |
First Team |
| 2009 | Lindon Ivezic Joe Deneweth John Faraj |
M |
First Team Second Team Honorable Mention |
| 2008 | Joe Zanni Joel Parrish John Faraj |
M F M |
First Team Second Team Honorable Mention |
| 2007 | Ryan Robleske Jeremy Romer |
D D |
First Team Second Team |
| 2006 | Jason Blickensdorf Aaron Chmiel Matt Konopinski Ryan Emerson Jeremy Romer |
GK D M M D |
First Team First Team First Team Second Team Second Team |
| 2005 | Matt Konopinski Paul Kujawski Brandon Smith Chris LaMasse |
M |
First Team Second Team Second Team Honorable Mention |
| 2004 |
Joe Russo |
First Team |
|
| 2003 | Josh Ruffles Joe Russo Carlos Escabar Brendan Welsh |
||
| 2002 | Josh Ruffles | ||
| 2001 | Sam Skeels Andy Power Steve Mazimpaka Josh Ruffles Brandon King |
||
| 2000 | B.J. Horn Sam Skeels Clement Irushabandi Andy Power |
||
| 1999 | B.J. Horn Nick DeKam Sam Skeels Clement Irushabandi Andy Power |
||
| 1998 | Jason Bolinger Nick DeKam B.J. Horn Sam Skeels |
||
| 1997 | Ridge Frew | ||
| 1996 | Ridge Frew | ||
| 1995 | Tad Golfmeyer | ||
| 1994 | Ridge Frew Tad Goldmeyer Charles Jergler |
Updated 12/08/23
