| Record | # | Player(s) | Opponent | Date |
| Goals | 8 | Eric Csizmadia | Cleary | 3/25/2022 |
| Assists | 7 | Garnet Potter Jake Gallaher |
Tennessee Wesleyan Taylor |
3/6/2019 4/13/2019 |
| Points | 10 | Shane Lewandowski Alex Gilbert Jake Gallaher |
Madonna UM-Dearborn Taylor |
4/12/2017 3/23/2019 4/13/2019 |
| Ground Balls | 28 | Fernando Robison | UM-Dearborn | 4/23/2022 |
| Caused Turnovers | 6 | Jordan Martin Jordan Martin Michael Birt III Ethan Wissink |
Saginaw Valley State Carnegie Mellon Aquinas Benedictine |
3/24/2012 4/7/2013 4/18/2018 3/9/2022 |
| Man-Up Goals | 3 | Spencer Macek Tom Kreitzer Alex Gilbert Eric Csizmadia Eric Csizmadia Eric Csizmadia Jake Gallaher |
Judson UM-Dearborn UM-Dearborn Lourdes Benedictine Lawrence Tech Indiana Tech |
4/20/2013 4/6/2014 3/23/2019 3/30/2022 3/11/2023 4/25/2023 4/12/2023 |
| Man-Down Goals | 1 | Spencer Macek Nate Woods Ben Lama Mike Cleary Dann Orr Nate Woods Garnet Potter Nolan Ryan |
Aquinas Ferris State Carnegie Mellon Lawrence Tech Dayton Lourdes Aquinas Tennessee Wesleyan |
3/30/2013 4/5/2013 4/7/2013 4/13/2013 5/1/2015 4/1/2016 4/18/2018 3/6/2019 |
| Saves | 36 | Julian Dortman | Ferris State | 4/2/2011 |
(Updated 5/25/2023)
