| Batting Average | Avg. | Year | |
| 1. | Jerry Koester | .396 | 93-94 |
| 2. | Cory Lehman | .348 | 09-12 |
| 3. | Brendan Green | .344 | 16-19 |
| 4. | Matt Pike | .340 | 97-00 |
| 5. | Chris Hudson | .336 | 03-07 |
| 6. | Dave Bonino | .332 | 87-90 |
| 7. | Adam Benschoter | .329 | 88-91 |
| 8. | John Hill | .327 | 96-99 |
| 9. | Freddy Jehle | .326 | 15-18 |
| 10. | Brian Jeffery | .324 | 00-02 |
| Hits | H | Year | |
| 1. | Mike Giacomantonio | 260 | 91-94 |
| 2. | Cory Lehman | 241 | 09-12 |
| 3. | Brendan Green | 208 | 16-19 |
| 4. | Matt Pike | 206 | 97-00 |
| 5. | Freddy Jehle | 199 | 15-18 |
| 6. | Dave Bonino | 197 | 87-90 |
| 7. | Adam Benschoter | 193 | 88-91 |
| 8. | Mike Lollo | 186 | 11-14 |
| 9. | Chris Husdon | 185 | 03-07 |
| 10. | Jerry Koester | 178 | 93-94 |
| Home Runs | HR | Year | |
| 1. | Mike Giacomantonio | 33 | 91-94 |
| 2. | Matt Pike | 25 | 97-00 |
| 3. | Chris Ogden | 24 | 95-98 |
| Dave Bonino | 24 | 87-90 | |
| 5. | John Hill | 20 | 96-99 |
| 6. | Paul Ferrell | 19 | 99-02 |
| Adam Benschoter | 19 | 88-91 | |
| 8. | Josh Burgett | 17 | 01-04 |
| 9. | Mike Heard | 16 | 89-90 |
| 10. | Brian Jeffery | 15 | 00-02 |
| Runs Batted In | RBI | Year | |
| 1. | Mike Giacomantonio | 195 | 91-94 |
| 2. | Matt Pike | 141 | 97-00 |
| 3. | John Hill | 139 | 96-99 |
| 4. | Dave Bonino | 127 | 87-90 |
| 5. | Adam Benschoter | 117 | 88-91 |
| 6. | Todd Falkner | 116 | 92-95 |
| 7. | Chris Ogden | 111 | 95-98 |
| 8. | Chris Hudson | 106 | 03-07 |
| 9. | Cory Lehman | 99 | 09-12 |
| 10. | Mark Pauwels | 96 | 07-10 |
| Brendan Green | 96 | 16-19 |
| Runs | R | Year | |
| 1. | Mike Giacomantonio | 165 | 91-94 |
| 2. | Matt Pike | 161 | 97-00 |
| 3. | Cory Lehman | 146 | 09-12 |
| 4. | Adam Benschoter | 142 | 88-91 |
| 5. | Josh Reeber | 139 | 94-97 |
| 6. | Freddy Jehle | 137 | 15-18 |
| 7. | Jerry Koester | 133 | 93-94 |
| 8. | Dave Bonino | 124 | 87-90 |
| 9. | Jack McGurk | 115 | 87-90 |
| 10. | Brendan Green | 113 | 16-19 |
| Doubles | 2B | Year | |
| 1. | Cory Lehman | 59 | 09-12 |
| 2. | John Hill | 55 | 96-99 |
| 3. | Matt Pike | 48 | 97-00 |
| 4. | Mike Giacomantonio | 47 | 91-94 |
| 5. | Brian Jeffery | 41 | 00-02 |
| 6. | Mark Pauwels | 38 | 07-10 |
| Mike Sepsey | 38 | 05-08 | |
| Bryan Kay | 38 | 01-04 | |
| 9. | Tim Stoddard | 37 | 06-09 |
| Dave Bonino | 37 | 87-90 |
| Triples | 3B | Year | |
| 1. | Adam Benschoter | 16 | 88-91 |
| 2. | Mike Giacomantonio | 14 | 91-94 |
| 3. | Josh Reeber | 13 | 94-97 |
| 4. | Matt Pike | 11 | 97-00 |
| 5. | Craig Matthews | 9 | 88-90 |
| Rob Puckett | 9 | 92-93 | |
| 7. | Brian Rochowiak | 8 | 89-91 |
| 8. | Cory Lehman | 7 | 09-12 |
| Jerry Koester | 7 | 93-94 | |
| 10. | Adam Wilding | 6 | 20-pres. |
| At-Bats | AB | Year | |
| 1. | Mike Giacomantonio | 817 | 91-94 |
| 2. | Cory Lehman | 706 | 09-12 |
| 3. | Mike Lollo | 641 | 11-14 |
| 4. | Freddy Jehle | 611 | 15-18 |
| 5. | Glen Scheerer | 610 | 93-96 |
| 6. | Todd Falkner | 609 | 92-95 |
| 7. | Matt Pike | 605 | 97-00 |
| Brendan Green | 605 | 16-19 | |
| 9. | Dave Bonino | 593 | 87-90 |
| 10. | Adam Benschoter | 586 | 88-91 |
| Stolen Bases | SB | Year | |
| 1. | Jerry Koester | 91 | 93-94 |
| 2. | Josh Reeber | 67 | 94-97 |
| 3. | Bob Szczechowski | 54 | 92-95 |
| 4. | Mike Giacomantonio | 53 | 91-94 |
| 5. | Freddy Jehle | 52 | 15-18 |
| 6. | Glen Scheerer | 43 | 93-96 |
| 7. | Jason Martines | 41 | 95-97 |
| 8. | Rob Puckett | 37 | 92-93 |
| 9. | Mike Sepsey | 35 | 05-08 |
| Adam Benschoter | 35 | 88-91 |
| Walks | BB | Year | |
| 1. | Dave Bonino | 156 | 87-90 |
| 2. | Jack McGurk | 126 | 87-90 |
| 3. | Bob Szczechowski | 120 | 92-95 |
| 4. | Todd Falkner | 92 | 92-95 |
| 5. | Joe DiMarco | 90 | 92-96 |
| Adam Benschoter | 90 | 88-91 | |
| 7. | Cole VanWasshenova | 89 | 20-pres. |
| 8. | Eric Justice | 83 | 96-98 |
| 9. | John Hill | 82 | 96-99 |
| Glen Scheerer | 82 | 93-96 |
| Wins | W | Year | |
| 1. | Todd Boike | 20 | 91-94 |
| 2. | Justin Black | 19 | 95-97 |
| 3. | Corey Alexander | 18 | 09-12 |
| 4. | Ken Szych | 17 | 95-98 |
| Jason Martines | 17 | 95-97 | |
| 6. | Bryan Gearhart | 16 | 94-97 |
| Al Stobinski | 16 | 87-89 | |
| 8. | Dennis Szczechowski | 14 | 89-92 |
| Reid Olmstead | 14 | 16-19 | |
| 10. | Tom Domkowski | 13 | 91-94 |
| Innings Pitched | IP | Year | |
| 1. | Todd Boike | 302.2 | 91-94 |
| 2. | Reid Olmstead | 256.1 | 16-19 |
| 3. | Ken Szych | 247.2 | 95-98 |
| 4. | Bryan Gearhart | 244.2 | 94-97 |
| 5. | Brett Kuebler | 244 | 09-12 |
| 6. | Chris Boertje | 237.2 | 06-07, 09-10 |
| 7. | Corey Alexander | 230 | 09-12 |
| 8. | Justin Black | 227 | 95-97 |
| 9. | Kevin Barkholz | 224.2 | 97-01 |
| 10. | Dennis Szczechowski | 209.2 | 89-92 |
| Strikeouts | K | Year | |
| 1. | Todd Boike | 182 | 91-94 |
| 2. | Phil Dunn | 162 | 01-04 |
| 3. | Reid Olmstead | 153 | 16-19 |
| 4. | Ken Szych | 151 | 95-98 |
| 5. | Corey Alexander | 144 | 09-12 |
| 6. | Justin Black | 143 | 95-97 |
| Dave Wood | 143 | 94-95 | |
| 8. | Bryan Gearhart | 141 | 94-97 |
| 9. | Dennis Szczechowski | 140 | 89-92 |
| 10. | Chris Boertje | 131 | 06-07, 09-10 |
| Earned Run Average (min. 100 IP) |
ERA | Year | |
| 1. | Dennis Szczechowski | 3.39 | 89-92 |
| 2. | Cory Bergfeld | 3.62 | 07-09 |
| 3. | Jason Martines | 3.66 | 95-97 |
| 4. | Corey Alexander | 3.68 | 09-12 |
| 5. | Al Stobinski | 3.85 | 87-89 |
| 6. | Bryan Gearhart | 3.97 | 94-97 |
| 7. | Brent Vaccaro | 4.08 | 13-pres. |
| 8. | Dave Wood | 4.17 | 94-95 |
| 9. | Reid Olmstead | 4.42 | 16-19 |
| 10. | Justin Black | 4.44 | 95-97 |
| Saves | S | Year | |
| 1. | Jake Kret | 13 | 10-13 |
| 2. | Ben Finn | 7 | 13-17 |
| . | Kevin Barkholz | 7 | 97-01 |
| 4. | Dan Winzeler | 6 | 93 |
| 5. | Dave Wood | 5 | 94-95 |
| Steve Sontag | 5 | 88 | |
| 7. | Jeremy Beal | 4 | 99 |
| 8. | Tony Flagg | 3 | 07-10 |
| Jack Cross | 3 | 06-09 | |
| Drew Ollila | 3 | 08-09 | |
| Scott Krause | 3 | 01-03 | |
| Matt Pike | 3 | 97-00 | |
| Dennis Szczechowski | 3 | 89-92 | |
| Jeff Arnston | 3 | 84 | |
| Brett Steele | 3 | 82-84 | |
| Trevor Willis | 3 | 16-18 | |
| Kenny Layman | 3 | 20-pres. |
| Complete Games | CG | Year | |
| 1. | Jason Martines | 23 | 95-97 |
| 2. | Ken Szych | 22 | 95-98 |
| 3. | Justin Black | 18 | 95-97 |
| 4. | Kevin Barkholz | 17 | 97-01 |
| Bryan Gearhart | 17 | 94-97 | |
| 6. | Corey Alexander | 16 | 09-12 |
| Phil Dunn | 16 | 01-04 | |
| 8. | Brett Kuebler | 14 | 09-12 |
| 9. | Dave Wood | 13 | 94-95 |
| 10. | Chris Boertje | 12 | 06-07, 09-10 |
