| 2023 |
Courtnee Chappetta Lauren Dioszegi Taylor Eppard Alexis Hirst Julia Hogston Kat Moreau Brenna Nurenberg Lyndsey Pena Sam Spicer Shyann Traux |
| 2022 |
Kiley Elbaor Lily Guerra Sam Hill Alexis Hirst Julia Hogston Janelle Krueger Milah Loose Brenna Nurenberg Lyndsey Pena Hannah Pennington Sam Spicer |
| 2021 |
Lily Guerra |
| 2020 |
Jordan Bianchi |
| 2019 |
Ashley Bearden |
| 2018 |
Lexi Agers |
| 2017 |
Ashley Best |
| 2016 | Hannah Bleikamp Lesley Ducat Katie Hybl Megan Jones Kenya Keller Kelsey Lampkowski Kyndle Wolfinger |
| 2015 | Jessie Arnold Mariah Boss Taylor Hayes Morgan Huttenlocker Tiffany Jones Bitty Treece Morgan Warfield |
| 2014 | Mariah Boss Taylor Hayes Megan Higdon Morgan Huttenlocker Ashley O'Leary Jenn Sylvester Bitty Treece Morgan Warfield |
| 2013 | Tonya Berta Jessica Lampkowski Katie O'Hotzke Ashley O'Leary |
| 2012 | Tonya Berta Jessica Lampkowski Brittney Rhodes Lizz Wilson |
| 2011 | Brittney Rhodes Lizz Wilson |
| 2010 | Dani Bailey Melissa Hall |
| 2009 | Hillary Day |
| 2008 |
Sarah Beaubien |
| 2007 | Sarah Beaubien Amber Daweritz Liz Harrison Julie Thomas |
| 2006 | Tina DePaw Ashley Garrow Julie Thomas |
